The independent voice of cricket

International Cricket

New Zealand-South Africa Cricket World Cup legends XI – who makes the cut?

by Oscar Ratcliffe 5 minute read

Who makes the cut in our New Zealand-South Africa Cricket World Cup composite XI?

Plenty of pace and power have been in evidence over the years from two sides still awaiting their first World Cup trophy.

South Africa boast a roster of players who are statistically exceptional at World Cups, but for all their talent have been found wanting in key moments. New Zealand have traditionally been a force when hosting tournaments but struggle to make a similar impact abroad, so often overshadowed by their antipodean neighbours.

1. Herschelle Gibbs (South Africa)

One of the best fielders in world cricket, at the 1999 tournament Gibbs famously dropped Steve Waugh celebrating before he had full control of the ball; a moment which signalled a shift in momentum away from favourites South Africa to eventual winners Australia. Gibbs had earlier that game made an authoritative 101. His other World Cup highlights include hitting six sixes in an over against the Netherlands in 2007, the first player to do so in ODI cricket.

1,067 CWC runs @56.15, 2 centuries

Herschelle Gibbs batting against New Zealand in Barbados on May 6, 2010

2. Gary Kirsten (South Africa)

Gary Kirsten’s 188* against the UAE in 1996 stood as the record for the highest World Cup score for 19 years. He averaged 78.20 in that tournament and opened the batting with Gibbs at the ’99 tournament hitting 82 against New Zealand. Unable to win the World Cup as a player, Kirsten coached India to their 2011 victory.

806 CWC runs @47.41, 1 century

South Africa’s Gary Kirsten in action during the ICC Cricket World Cup 2003

3. Martin Crowe (New Zealand)

Crowe was the main driver behind co-hosts New Zealand’s run to the ‘92 semi-final. With 456 runs at an average of 114, some inventive captaincy (Crowe was one of the first to open with spin bowlers in ODI cricket as well as an early advocate of pinch hitters) and 100* against Australia led to a hard-earned Player of the Tournament award for the Kiwi skipper.

880 CWC runs @55.00, 1 century

New Zealand’s Martin Crowe on his way to an unbeaten century, 1992

4. AB de Villiers (South Africa)

With the second most sixes in the tournament’s history (37) and a strike rate of 117.29, de Villiers was an intimidating presence in World Cup cricket. Serving notice of his talent in 2007 with a punkish 92 from 70 against the all-conquering Aussie side, AB took hitting to hitherto unseen levels in 2015 when he creamed 162* from 66 balls against the West Indies.

1,207 CWC runs @63.52, 4 centuries

South Africa’s AB de Villiers reacts during a 2015 Cricket World Cup semi-final

5. Scott Styris (New Zealand)

The underrated Styris epitomises many of Blackcap cricket’s qualities. More than the sum of his parts, the all-rounder was a mainstay in the middle order for New Zealand from 2007 to 2011 with two World Cup centuries against the Sri Lankans and a handful of wickets with his crafty medium pace.

909 CWC runs @53.47, 2 centuries; 17 CWC wickets @32.47

Scott Styris hits the ball towards the boundary in the 2011 World Cup semi-final

6. Brendon McCullum (New Zealand) (C) (WK)

As skipper at the 2015 World Cup Brendon McCullum seemingly cracked the ODI code. New Zealand set out to be ultra-aggressive regardless of match situation and embarked on a breath-taking run to the final. The elevation in modern scoring rates owes much to McCullum’s blueprint. No slouch himself, of batsmen to have hit more than 500 World Cup runs McCullum has the highest strike-rate.

742 CWC runs @33.72, 1 century

Brendon McCullum shakes hands with Michael Clarke in front of World Cup trophy

7. Lance Klusener (South Africa)

Player of the Tournament at the 1999 World Cup, Klusener was the prototype of the modern, hard-hitting ODI No.7. Memories of the all-rounder can seldom be divorced from that final over in the semi-final against Australia where, having squeezed two yorkers for boundaries, he was involved in the fatalistic run out which led to a tie and the end of South Africa’s World Cup hopes.

372 CWC runs @124.00; 22 CWC wickets @22.12, 1 five-for

South Africa’s Lance Klusener batting against Australia during the 1999 Cricket World Cup

8. Daniel Vettori (New Zealand)

The bespectacled, parsimonious left-arm spinner was an ever present for New Zealand’s 2015 campaign. He took 15 wickets at 20.46, including 4-18 from 10 against Afghanistan, a perfect response to a disappointing 2011 tournament where in helpful sub-continent conditions he could only manage three wickets.

36 CWC wickets @32.44

New Zealand’s Daniel Vettori fields during the 2015 Cricket World Cup semi-final

9. Richard Hadlee (New Zealand)

Hadlee played in the first three World Cups and helped New Zealand to two semi-finals. Against Sri Lanka at Bristol in the 1983 tournament the great Kiwi all-rounder took a career best 5-25.

22 CWC wickets @19.13, 1 five-for

Richard Hadlee bowling for New Zealand during the Prudential World Cup in 1983

10. Shane Bond (New Zealand)

Fast bowler Bond’s injury-ravaged, stop-start career coincided with two World Cups. With 6-23 against Australia in 2003 an undoubted highlight, 13 wickets also came in the 2007 edition of the tournament at less than 20 runs apiece as New Zealand made the last four.

30 CWC wickets @17.26, 1 five-for

New Zealand’s Shane Bond celebrates the wicket of Chamara Silva, 2007

11. Allan Donald (South Africa)

Come the ’99 World Cup Donald was the premier fast bowler in world cricket. It is therefore something of a tragedy that the enduring image of the tournament is Donald batless, stranded miles out of his ground as Adam Gilchrist whips the bails off, running him out and damning that great South African side to a ‘chokers’ epitaph. Earlier in the tournament, the fast bowler known as ‘White Lightning’ struck England with 4-27 en route to the hosts crashing out of their own World Cup.

South Africa’s Allan Donald celebrates dismissal of Arjuna Ranatunga, 1999

38 CWC wickets @24.02


Have Your Say

Become a Wisden member

  • Exclusive offers and competitions
  • Money-can’t-buy experiences
  • Join the Wisden community
  • Sign up for free
Latest magazine

Get the magazine

12 Issues for just £39.99