India have dropped Mohammed Siraj for the Wellington Test against New Zealand. So why have they taken the shock selection call?
Siraj was second in the Test pecking order, behind Jasprit Bumrah, but what captain Shubman Gill’s pre-match comments hinted at was confirmed at the toss. India had dropped Siraj, with both Akash Deep and Anshul Kamboj picked instead. Bumrah and Prasidh Krishna completed the four-pronged pace attack.
"There were signs when he did not join the Test squad early,” Gavaskar said on Sony Sports after the toss. “I thought they were going to play him when he played in the final ODI. But this is a surprise. I don't think he has let India down. He has never let India down.
“Nothing that has gone wrong with his bowling. His rhythm is good. He has been fine, from what I observed of whatever cricket he has played recently. Why he has not been picked is something I don't know. I only hope the others who have been picked ahead of him deliver.”
Harsha Bhogle was also taken aback by the call, highlighting how the workhorse had pulled India out of trouble many a time in Bumrah’s absence - the 2025 Oval Test against England being a recent case in point.
“Flabbergasted and disappointed that India have left out Siraj,” he posted on X. “He has done everything asked of him, lifted the attack in the absence of Bumrah, been a great, positive team player. You have to wish Kamboj well but I hope there are some very honest conversations with Siraj taking place.”
So why was Mohammed Siraj dropped?
The selection call seemed to be in the making when Gill suggested during his pre-match press conference that batting depth would play a role in deciding the final XI. Him pointing out that both Akash Deep and Kamboj “can bat a bit” was probably what tilted the balance in the duo's favour.
“There are a lot of factors we’ll take into consideration, including batting depth,” he said. “Ideally, we’re looking at seven proper batsmen, and then the eighth and ninth positions will depend on the combination. Akash can bat a bit, Anshul can bat a bit, and even if we go with Reddy, he’s a proper batsman.”
Bowling coach Morne Morkel dodged the Siraj question in his pre-match presser. “Siraj is a world-class performer, whenever he has stepped in India jersey, whenever he has played,” he said on the eve of the first Test. “My feedback to Gautam [Gambhir] was that we have enough in attack to take 20 wickets. Ultimately the call will be taken by Shubman.”
“Quite tough, you know,” Gill said at the toss. “We were contemplating for the past one week which combination to, you know, go with because all of our fast bowlers have been doing really well. You know, very difficult for Siraj and Gurnoor [Brar] for both of them to miss out, you know. They did decently well in the ODI series. Siraj and Gurnoor obviously, was man of the series there. So it was a hard decision for us. But hopefully, all the fast bowlers that we picked, they should be able to do the job for us.”
Siraj’s recent form may have played a role too. He has taken five wickets at 28.60 in three Tests this year – two in Sri Lanka and one against Afghanistan in New Chandigarh. The dip in his pace during the Sri Lanka series was a talking point, and also in the Duleep Trophy final that followed, where he picked up just one wicket and conceded 187 runs across the two innings. As per Siraj’s own admission, he is a rhythm bowler and needs consistency to build up to his best. Across the three Tests this year, he bowled
“Every bowler's body is different, but mine doesn't handle long breaks well,” Siraj told Cricbuzz after the Duleep Trophy final. “A short breather is fine, but in my 10-year career, I had never taken two full months off. I was working out in the gym and bowling occasionally, but no amount of practice can replicate match intensity. It was a new experience, but a valuable learning curve for me going forward.
“I'm purely a rhythm bowler. If I'm not in sync, I simply can't explode through the crease. That was the struggle in Sri Lanka - my run-up felt disjointed. Some strides were too short, others were too long, and that broke my flow and cost me pace. Out here, everything clicked into place, and the pace followed naturally.”
Siraj was notably part of the India ODI squad for all five matches on the tour, where again, the popular perception was that he was second in the pecking order behind Bumrah. And with the leader of India’s pace attack missing, he was a shoo-in to assume that role, but he played just one match.
Since arriving in New Zealand in late October, Siraj has played only two matches – one unofficial Test for India A against New Zealand A and the fifth ODI. How that could affect his rhythm and eventually his Test and ODI World Cup spots is anybody's guess.
Follow Wisden for all cricket updates, including live scores, match stats, quizzes and more. Stay up to date with the latest cricket news, player updates, team standings, match highlights, video analysis and live match odds.