Winners and losers from England's first Test squad of the new Joe Root era

With the first Test of the series against Pakistan less than two weeks away, the squad provided some answers over what England will look like in a post-Stokes world, although perhaps solid decisions will wait until Stephen Fleming takes up his positions as head coach over the winter.

England squad: Joe Root (c), Jofra Archer, Gus Atkinson, Shoaib Bashir, Harry Brook, Brydon Carse, Sam Cook, Jordan Cox, Ben Duckett, Matthew Fisher, Emilio Gay, Dan Lawrence, Ollie Pope, Ollie Robinson, Jamie Smith, Josh Tongue.

Winners

Dan Lawrence

Lawrence has been recalled to England’s Test squad for the first time in two years, and is carded to bat at No.6, with Jamie Smith returning to No.7. His inclusion provides the first answer in how England will look to balance their side in the post-Stokes world, as the all-rounder in their top six. However, his position in the XI means England will lack a seam-bowling all-rounder – the age-old problem they’ve faced whenever Stokes hasn’t been available. His selection pushes Will Jacks, who filled the same role in Australia over the winter, and Rehan Ahmed, down the pecking order of spin-bowling all-rounders.

Ollie Pope

Pope’s recall is the most eye-catching news from the squad. Having been dropped in Australia and replaced at No.3 by Jacob Bethell, the road back into the Test team looked difficult in the immediate future. While he had a good start to the County Championship in the spring, he hasn’t ripped up the run-scoring charts in the way Lawrence has. However, the injury to Bethell, which will see him miss the whole series, has opened a door. While Pope isn’t a direct replacement for Bethell, with Jordan Cox set to bat at No.3, he replaces Cox as the spare batter and keeper in the group, overtaking James Rew in that particular pecking order.

Sam Cook

Having been left out of Test squads since making his debut against Zimbabwe last year, Cook makes up a pool of seven seamers England have selected for the series. They are likely to field four specialist seamers, leaving room for Cook to come into a more varied attack. While he likely doesn’t fit into the first-choice of that group, his inclusion ahead of Sonny Baker signals a move away from the all-out pace strategy that was implemented during the Stokes-McCullum era.

Ollie Robinson

Robinson was recalled for England’s Test series against New Zealand, and made an instant mark with a scintillating spell at Lord’s. However, the injury problems which plagued his original stint as a Test player, and caused friction over his fitness with team management, returned for the following match at The Oval. He wasn’t included in England’s XI for the third Test despite being passed fit. His inclusion in Root’s first Test squad is another lifeline, from the captain who first brought him into the fold.

Jordan Cox

Cox is the sole survivor of the three debutants from The Oval Test match, having leapfrogged Rew for the final game of the New Zealand series. While Cox only made scores of 27 and 25 in the hammering at The Oval, there was enough there to warrant a second look. The injury to Bethell means that he will get a run up the order to bat at three, a more similar role to the one he fills for Essex after dropping down to No.7 on Test debut. The only possible detractor for Cox is Pope’s inclusion in the side. Even though Cox will likely be given the full series, a former England Test No.3 will be waiting in the wings if England do decide they need a replacement.

Losers

James Rew

Rew is the most obvious one to miss out from the squad announcement. While he was left out of the Trent Bridge Test after failing to impress with either bat or gloves at The Oval, Pope’s elevation above him as Smith’s back-up will be a blow. As a player who came in off the back of repeated calls for his elevation, and with an avalanche of domestic runs under his belt, it will be a disappointment to end his summer further away than he started having made his England debut.

Sam Curran

The extent to which Sam Curran was ever in with a shout of a Test recall is slightly dampened by the niggle he’s picked up in The Hundred, which has hampered his ability to bowl. Nevertheless, in the search for a Stokes replacement, Curran is one of the few on the county circuit who could fit in a similar balancing position in the side. Missing the series might work in Curran’s favour, however. When the big decisions are made upon Fleming’s arrival, there may be fewer black marks against Curran’s name than if he were included in a tentative first squad.

Sonny Baker

None of Baker’s England debuts across formats have gone to plan. He conceded disastrous figures in both of his white-ball international debuts, and hasn’t played in either format since. On Test debut at The Oval, his figures across both innings read 3-161, and returned the most expensive economy rate for a debutant England seamer who bowled at least 200 deliveries in his first innings. Having been on the fast-track for the last 18 months, Baker now looks set for a stint on the sidelines.

Rehan Ahmed

Ahmed was named in the first Test squad of the summer amid uncertainty over how England would look to address their post-Ashes spin role. However, Stokes and McCullum plumped for Bashir, and decided to go in without a specialist spinner or spin-bowling all-rounder when Stokes was absent at The Oval. The inclusion of Lawrence will be a particular blow for Ahmed, who continued his run of form with the bat with a century in the early rounds of the County Championship before he was pulled out for England duty. The wait for how England may eventually fit Ahmed into their Test plans will continue for another summer.

Shoaib Bashir

Although Bashir has been named in this Test squad, it’s hard not to come away with the impression that he is the player set to lose the most from Stokes’ retirement. Not only has he lost the captain who got more out of him than any other, his position in the side is always the one in most jeopardy when Stokes is absent. As it is, he looks likely to lose his position with the inclusion of Lawrence, with England set to use him as a way to field a four-man pace attack. That will leave no room for Bashir, and more questions over how young English spinners are managed in the early stages of their careers.

Follow Wisden for all cricket updates, including live scores, match stats, quizzes and more. Stay up to date with the latest cricket news, player updates, team standings, match highlights, video analysis and live match odds.