The injury substitution trial in the 2026 County Championship has been described as "absolute nonsense" by former England batter Mark Butcher, after a number of controversial replacements.
Mark Butcher: I don’t blame the counties, but the trial is absolute nonsense
Speaking on Wisden Cricket Weekly podcast, Butcher said he "despised" the trial. "I can’t think of any good reason as to why you would need to bring that into the game of cricket," he said. "I understand it’s an experiment, but I’m not a fan at all."
The ECB are reportedly considering changes to their injury replacement trial after several controversial incidents. In the latest round of County Championship fixtures, Lancashire were prevented from using Tom Bailey as a replacement for Ajeet Singh Dale, who suffered a hamstring problem on day one against Gloucestershire. Match referee Peter Such rejected Bailey as a replacement on the grounds that he was not like-for-like. Lancashire instead called Ollie Sutton – a left-arm seamer – up from a second XI match, to replace Dale – a right-arm quick.
Previous replacements have also sparked criticism of the rules, with Hampshire head coach Russell Domingo jokingly saying he could 'give his players laxatives' to benefit from a fresher replacement. In the previous round of fixtures, Nottinghamshire were able to benefit from calling up fresh seamer Lyndon James as a replacement for injured Fergus O'Neill on the final day of their game against Glamorgan.
"I don’t blame any of the counties who have called on the rule and used it to their advantage because it is there to be taken advantage of," said Butcher. "The only thing that baffles me really is that anyone is surprised that humans in a competitive atmosphere wouldn’t use every single advantage that they possibly could at the first opportunity they got to do it. It really is extraordinary, I don’t like it at all.
"I know this came up as a big talking point with the Chris Woakes thing last year against India at The Oval, and I’m not saying that it was great because it was a great spectacle of him walking down the steps [with his arm in a sling], of course it wasn’t. But unfortunately, cricket, sport, most sports, like life itself, is not very fair sometimes, and that’s just tough. So that is the way I would like it to stay."
The ECB's trial comes as part of a wider trial by the ICC of using replacements in first-class games. The issue was highlighted when Chris Woakes came out to bat in the final innings of England's Test against India at The Oval last summer, despite having sustained a serious shoulder injury earlier in the game.
County Championship injury replacement trial: Full list of players subbed in and out so far
Similar trials have been run in Australia, India and South Africa, although the ECB's parameters for replacement are wider than those used elsewhere. Under the current rules, players can be replaced due to 'significant life events', as well as injury, and the period during which they are stood down from selection after being replaced is shorter. Players can also be replaced at any point during a fixture, while in the Sheffield Shield trial, players could only be replaced during the first two days of the game.
"Death in the family or whatever it might be, even me with my hardline view on it, would go ‘okay, that’s fine’ – we can find a way to work around that," said Butcher. "The guard rails need to be much, much, much tighter. I would venture to suggest that injury is not a good enough reason for a replacement. I would take that out of the equation altogether and you just have to suck it up, as teams for 100 years have had to suck it up when you lose a player for injury if you can’t carry on.
"You’re asking officials, and umpires, and match referees and people like that to become involved in making decisions about whether a player is fit enough to continue for the rest of the game. That’s not their job. I think we leave things as they are and be sensible about the rare occasions on which a replacement would be entirely appropriate. You’ve got concussion subs and medically that is sound, fine, that stats. But, a hamstring or something, sorry that’s part of the game.
"It also gives you the opportunity as a captain or a coach going into the game, the way things are at the moment anyway, to take a risk on a half-fit player. You pick a half fit player, you get an innings out of them and then you’re able to replace them in the second. It’s just nonsense, absolute bull dust."
Follow Wisden for all cricket updates, including live scores, match stats, quizzes and more. Stay up to date with the latest cricket news, player updates, team standings, match highlights, video analysis and live match odds.
